Welcome, Tarnished, to another thrilling deep dive into the ever-expanding lore of Elden Ring DLC! With the release of the “Shadow of the Earth Tree” DLC, fans have been buzzing with theories and discussions. One topic that’s been making waves is the role of Melina. Many believe she didn’t have a significant part in the DLC, but I’m here to tell you that’s not the case! So, grab some juicy prawns, sit back, and let’s unravel the fascinating story of Messmer and Meline, whether Messmer killed Melina or not in the Elden Ring DLC.
The Mystery of the Butterflies
Elden Ring’s base game introduced us to three significant butterflies, believed to symbolize the children of Radagon and Marika:
- Nascent Butterfly: Implies Miquella, just emerging from a cocoon.
- Aeonia Butterfly: Directly linked to Malenia Scarlet Bloom.
- Smouldering Butterfly: Initially thought to be Melina.
With the DLC, we now have the Black Pyrefly Butterfly, tied to Messmer. This leaves us questioning the true identity of the Smouldering Butterfly. I strongly believe it’s Melina.
Connecting the Dots: Melina and Messmer
In an earlier version of the DLC, an item description from Messmer’s Kindling hinted that Melina is Messmer’s younger sister. It stated, “Messmer, much like his younger sister, bore a vision of fire.”
Both siblings have a deep connection to fire: Melina uses herself as kindling, and upon defeating Messmer, we receive his kindling. Their shared fascination with fire is a crucial clue.
Also check out: Best Weapons in Elden Ring DLC
Why Was This Information Removed?
You might wonder why this significant detail was removed. I think From Software decided it was too revealing. They love their mysteries, and spelling it out might have been too much. But don’t worry, there’s enough information in the DLC to piece together the story ourselves.
The Tragic Tale of Messmer and Melina
Marika once cared deeply for Messmer, but he was eventually sent to the land of shadows, forced to fight against the Hornbsent who tortured his people. The question is, why? The answer lies with Melina.
The Burnt and Bodiless Mystery
Melina is described as burnt and bodiless, but how did this happen? Given her fascination with fire and her connection to Messmer, I believe he unintentionally caused her condition. The powerful flame Messmer possesses could easily have been the cause.
Marika’s Change of Heart
After Melina’s tragic fate, Marika’s attitude towards Messmer changed. The scorch marks outside the Erd Tree gate where we fight Godfrey hint at a fiery outburst.
It’s possible that Messmer’s uncontrolled flames burnt Melina, leading her to seek refuge within the Erd Tree before her soul was tasked by Marika to become the Fire Maiden.
Twins and Their Curses
In Elden Ring, twins are seen as opposites:
- Mikala and Melania: Eternal youth and vitality vs. rotting decay from Scarlet Rot.
- Messmer and Melina: Messmer has a curse in his right eye, while Melina has one in her left eye, each sealed by different marks.
Also check out: Elden Ring DLC All Special Effect Armor Ranked
The Gloam-Eyed Queen Theory
Many believe Melina is the Gloam-Eyed Queen. The timeline fits, as Melina would be alive during the same period. Her powers also contrast with Messmer’s bright red flame, with her possessing a black flame that kills gods.
Further Evidence and Theories
- Round Table Hold Transportation: The instant transportation when touching Melina’s hand resembles how we are transported to the land of shadows by touching the withered arm in the DLC. This power similarity suggests a deeper connection.
- Melina’s Hair: Her pink hair, a lighter shade of Radigan’s red hair, supports the idea that she is a child of Radigan and Marika.
Vulgar Militias
These forces, which possess death incantations, might have once been part of Melina’s (as the Gloam-Eyed Queen) forces before joining Malekith.
Eye Curses
When the seals on their eyes are lifted, Melina’s eye reveals a gloam-colored abyss, and Messmer’s shows a serpent. This visual connection further supports the twin theory.
Conclusion
The evidence strongly suggests that Messmer and Melina are twins, intertwined by their powers, curses, and tragic fates. Their story adds a rich layer to the lore of Elden Ring, filling in many blanks and answering long-standing questions.
In short, yes, Messmer did kill Melina in Elden Ring DLC which is why Melina’s body was burned, remaining bodiless and a fire spirit with no memories and purpose roaming around. She was made a fire spirit by Queen Marika, and she was also the one who banished Messmer into the Shadow Realm because his flames were uncontrollable, sealing the snake into his left eye to control his powers.
Thank you for joining us on this lore-filled journey! Until next time, may you find your worth in the waking world. Goodbye, Tarnished!
